Disappointment Reigns in Lincoln Center’s “Uncle Vanya” Production

Key Takeaways:
– Anton Chekhov’s “Uncle Vanya” production at the Lincoln Center feels disconnected and disappointing.
– Talented cast, including Steve Carell and Alfred Molina, fails to blend well.
– Heidi Schreck’s translation is believed to lack cohesiveness.
– The setting and costumes depict temporal confusion, obstructing the clarity of the story.
– Audience finds it challenging to connect with the play due to a lack of successful comic reliefs.

Despite Bearing a Stellar Cast, “Uncle Vanya” Disappoints

While Anton Chekhov’s “Uncle Vanya” isn’t typically easy to execute or watch, the recent Lincoln Center production takes it to a new level of dissatisfaction. Despite housing a group of renowned and capable actors, including Steve Carell, Alfred Molina, Anika Noni Rose, Jayne Houdyshell, and Alison Pill, the performance disappointingly lacked cohesiveness.

Examining the Actor Performances

Alfred Molina, who portrays an obliviously self-centered character, is the only one who manages to deliver a secure performance. The remaining cast seems to be performing in separate spheres on the sizable Lincoln Center stage. Mimi Lien’s scenic design concept, although visually pleasing, minimizes the significance of the actors’ performances on stage.

The Disconnect in Performances

Albeit a well-orchestrated cast, the performances feel like they’re happening in isolation. A humorous escape, typically essential to this drama, is scarce, making the production feel rather alienating. One notable scene that sparks interest is when it rains on stage, drawing attention to the stage’s drainage system, an unusual point of focus.

The Role of Direction and Translation

Alongside the palpable disconnection, Heidi Schreck’s translation also falls into disarray. Despite displaying a clever adaptation in places, it fails to connect as either a contemporary interpretation or an amplified version of the 1895 play.

Temporal confusion worsens the issue. Kaye Voyce’s costumes read modern but significantly contradict the dialogue and the period setting. Therefore, “Uncle Vanya”, which generally requires a clear viewpoint to succeed, becomes challenging to comprehend in this production.

Other Translations and Performances

Comparing with other translations, Annie Baker’s rendition seems superior as it effectively connects the Russian text to its absurdist roots. On different notes, Alison Pill’s portrayal of Sonya stands out as empathetic, despite the character’s excessive stage mobility which makes it difficult for audiences to follow. Similarly, Jayne Houdyshell’s performance as Waffles catches attention occasionally but fails to construct a consistent character arc.

Carell’s portrayal of the titular character is reflected in an angry light. Although valid considering the context, Carell seems to be missing the core essence of his character, focusing excessively on the tragic aspects while compromising the comedic elements. Falling into the timeless trap of playing a tragicomic role, Carell fails to strike the balance.

In Closing

Despite the anticipation built around a well-established cast and director, the Lincoln Center Production of “Uncle Vanya” disappoints on various fronts. Whether it be an inconsistent cast performance, misplaced translation, or an unclear temporal setup, the renowned drama fails to find a firm footing. This leaves the audience struggling to connect with the characters and plot, diminishing overall satisfaction derived from the production.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here