Key takeaways:

• Marc Wortman warns Trump may deploy troops in US cities beyond Washington, D.C.
• Wordman says Trump first tried this plan in his first term but faced roadblocks.
• The Insurrection Act gives the president power to use the military at home.
• A clash could erupt between state governments, civilians, and the federal government.
• Service members might face legal and moral dilemmas if they must obey disputed orders.

Insurrection Act Powers Under Scrutiny

Marc Wortman, an independent journalist, spoke on MSNBC’s Weekend Primetime. He argued that Donald Trump has long wanted to send National Guard troops into cities across America. However, he struggled with his first administration. Now, according to Wortman, Trump has removed most officials who opposed him in his second term. As a result, the chances of using military power at home have grown.

Wortman said he sees a plan forming. He thinks Trump wants to invoke the Insurrection Act to override local leaders. That move could spark a fight over federalism. Moreover, it could pit the federal government against state governments. Even worse, civilians could face troops in the streets.

How the Insurrection Act Works

The Insurrection Act dates to 1807. It lets the president order troops to quell rebellion or domestic violence. Under this law, federal soldiers can act inside the United States. Yet, presidents have used it only six times in history. Most people do not know about it. Still, it grants broad power.

If the president invokes the Insurrection Act, governors lose some control over their National Guard. Then the military answers directly to the president. Thus, state leaders cannot stop troops from acting. In addition, federal forces can arrest people and clear streets. This power can help during riots or rebellions. But it can also turn into a tool to suppress protests.

Why Trump’s Plan Raises Red Flags

First, deploying troops to American cities outside Washington is rare. Second, Trump’s critics worry he might use force to stop protests or political dissent. Third, state governments may refuse to cooperate. Fourth, law enforcement could get caught in the middle.

Furthermore, Wortman warns the plan is not just hypothetical. He said Trump first sketched this idea during his first term. Yet, strong opposition in his cabinet and staff blocked it. Now, with fewer critics around him, the idea could move forward. Therefore, Wortman sees real danger ahead.

Potential Clash Over Federalism

Federalism means states share power with the national government. Each state is a sovereign entity with its own laws and leaders. Meanwhile, the president leads the federal government.

If Trump invokes the Insurrection Act, he challenges that balance. States may refuse to give up control of their guards. They could say the orders are illegal. In turn, the federal government may force its will. This clash could play out in courtrooms or on the streets.

Moreover, states might pass laws to defend their rights. They could block troop deployments or order state troops to resist. Such moves might deepen political divisions. They could also test the limits of democracy in the United States.

What Military Members Could Face

Enlisting in the military means following orders. Soldiers pledge to obey lawful commands. Yet, Wortman says they may face serious dilemmas if orders seem unconstitutional.

If they join federal troops under the Insurrection Act, they could get orders they find unjust. Then, they must decide: obey or refuse? Disobeying might lead to court-martial, loss of pay, or worse. Some could even face charges of treason. On the other hand, following unlawful orders can violate their personal moral code. It could also break the law. Thus, soldiers face a no-win choice.

How Could It Unfold?

First, Trump might publicly announce his intent to use the Insurrection Act. Then, governors could challenge him in court. Meanwhile, the military would prepare plans for domestic operations. Next, troops could arrive in cities that saw unrest or protest.

During any operation, soldiers would patrol streets, enforce curfews, and make arrests. Local police might team up with them, or they might clash. Citizens could protest the military presence. In that case, the situation could become volatile. Above all, the risk of mistakes or rights violations would grow.

What Comes Next?

At this stage, all eyes are on Trump’s administration. People are watching who remains in top positions. Key allies who back tough measures could push the plan forward. Yet, other officials may still oppose it behind the scenes.

Lawmakers in Congress could also step in. They can hold hearings, pass new laws, or block funding for troop deployments. Courts could rule that using the Insurrection Act without real rebellion is unconstitutional. In short, checks and balances will be tested.

Why This Matters to You

Even if you never plan to protest, this issue touches your life. It concerns how our democracy works. It affects the balance between state and federal power. It shapes how the military serves its own citizens. Finally, it sets precedents that future presidents will follow.

In the end, Wortman’s warning urges all of us to pay attention. We need to know how the Insurrection Act operates. We should watch our leaders carefully. Moreover, we must defend democratic norms and state rights.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often has the Insurrection Act been used?

In American history, presidents have invoked the Insurrection Act only six times. It remains a rare and powerful tool for domestic action.

Can state governors stop the president from using the Insurrection Act?

Governors can refuse to cooperate and challenge the order in court. However, the federal government can still deploy troops under its constitutional power.

What risks do soldiers face under the Insurrection Act?

Soldiers may receive orders they believe are illegal. Disobeying can lead to court-martial and severe punishment. Obeying potentially unlawful orders can violate their moral beliefs and rights.

Could Congress block a president’s use of the Insurrection Act?

Yes. Congress can pass laws or cut funding to prevent or limit troop deployments. It can also hold hearings to challenge the president’s actions.