Key Takeaways

• Pro-Trump and MAGA voices slammed Curtis Silwa after his debate showings.
• Silwa is the lone Republican in a three-way New York City mayor race.
• Critics say he failed to praise Donald Trump and risks helping socialist Zohran Mamdani.
• Calls grow for Curtis Silwa to drop out to avoid splitting the anti-Mamdani vote.

Overview of the New York City Race

Curtis Silwa, a well-known radio host, stands as the only Republican running for mayor of New York City. He faces socialist frontrunner Zohran Mamdani and independent Andrew Cuomo, the former governor. Meanwhile, former President Donald Trump has openly tried to influence the contest. He warns that federal funding for the city might vanish if Mamdani wins. At the same time, whispers suggest Trump’s administration struck a deal to back Cuomo, though Cuomo denies it.

Curtis Silwa’s Debate Performance

During a marathon two-hour debate, moderators asked each candidate to name the best president in U.S. history. To many viewers’ surprise, Curtis Silwa did not name Donald Trump. Instead, he sidestepped the question with a generalized answer about leadership qualities. As a result, right-wing pundits erupted online.

Laura Loomer’s criticism was swift. She pointed out that not a single candidate, including Silwa, said Trump. She called his answer “lame” and urged him to quit the race. Soon after, comedian Zach Sage Fox—who runs Cuomo’s social media account—jokingly claimed Silwa had effectively endorsed Mamdani.

Why Pro-Trump Voices Target Curtis Silwa

First, conservatives expect any Republican candidate to publicly back Trump. They see loyalty as key to keeping the base united. Second, they fear a split vote could hand the race to Mamdani, a self-described socialist. Third, Trump has already shown he can sway Republican contests with simple statements on social media.

Bill Ackman, a hedge fund manager, praised Silwa’s passion and knowledge of the city. Yet he warned that Silwa’s ego might cost him. Ackman urged, “A vote for Silwa is a vote for Mamdani.” He believes Silwa cannot win and should step aside.

Ellie Cohanim, former deputy envoy to combat antisemitism, also demanded Silwa drop out “if you actually care about New York.” Her post added to the growing chorus urging his exit.

Pressure Mounts for Curtis Silwa to Exit the Race

With each harsh critique, more voices call for Curtis Silwa to bow out. Polls show him trailing far behind both Mamdani and Cuomo. His vote share hovers in the low single digits. Republican strategists worry that sticking around could split anti-socialist votes and guarantee a left-wing win.

Moreover, the party’s base in New York depends on a unified front. If Silwa remains, members fear disunity will sap energy, volunteers, and donations. Several grassroots leaders have privately urged Silwa to withdraw. They argue he could preserve his reputation by stepping aside now.

On the other hand, Silwa’s campaign insists he won’t quit. He claims he offers a fresh perspective and can rally moderates and independents. His team points to his deep knowledge of city issues, from crime to homelessness. Still, critics say his debate answers lacked the fire and clarity needed to turn skeptics into supporters.

How Trump’s Influence Shapes the Contest

President Trump’s threats to cut federal funds if Mamdani wins have made headlines. He also praised Cuomo at a recent rally, adding fuel to rumors of a secret deal. Cuomo has repeatedly denied any agreement, but skeptics remain.

In this tug-of-war, Curtis Silwa finds himself squeezed between two powerful forces. On one side, Trump’s base demands open loyalty. On the other, independent voters worried about stability might lean toward Cuomo if Silwa appears weak.

Possible Paths Forward for Curtis Silwa

First, he could dig in and continue his campaign. To succeed, Silwa would need to sharpen his messaging and clearly state who he admires. He must show voters he stands for something unique, not just anti-socialism. He also needs to boost grassroots outreach in all five boroughs.

Second, he might negotiate a role in another campaign. Some suggest Silwa could endorse Cuomo in exchange for a policy advisory position. That move could unify anti-Mamdani forces but risk alienating hard-core Republicans.

Third, the most talked-about option is dropping out. If Curtis Silwa exits, he could still influence the race by urging supporters to back Cuomo. That might ensure Mamdani does not win. However, leaving the race mid-stream could damage Silwa’s credibility for future runs.

What This Means for New York City

A split vote between Silwa and Cuomo seems likely to pave the way for Mamdani’s victory. City leaders warn that a socialist mayor could restructure services, taxes, and policing. Conversely, a Cuomo win might mean moderate policies and a return to more centrist governance.

If Curtis Silwa stays in, conservatives risk losing New York City’s mayoral race for the first time in decades. In turn, national Republicans could see this as another sign of urban areas slipping from their grasp. Meanwhile, Democrats and independents watch closely, aware that NYC’s outcome may influence elections in other major cities.

Final Thoughts on Curtis Silwa’s Campaign

Curtis Silwa entered the race as a bold outsider. He promised to challenge the political establishment and bring fresh energy. Yet recent events have tested his ability to navigate a high-stakes contest. The criticism from MAGA influencers highlights the tightrope he must walk. Loyalty to Trump matters, but so does appealing to a broader electorate tired of polarized politics.

Over the next weeks, voters will judge whether Curtis Silwa can sharpen his message, win over skeptics, and prove his campaign has real momentum. Or they might decide his presence serves only to weaken the anti-socialist front. Either way, his next moves could decide New York City’s political future.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did Curtis Silwa say in the debate that upset MAGA voices?

He avoided naming Donald Trump as the best president in history. Instead, he offered a general leadership answer, which critics found disappointing.

Why are pro-Trump figures urging Curtis Silwa to drop out?

They fear he can’t win and that his continued candidacy will split votes, making it easier for socialist Zohran Mamdani to win.

Could Curtis Silwa still turn his campaign around?

Possibly. He would need to sharpen his messaging, clearly state his loyalties, and ramp up city-wide outreach to gain traction.

How might Silwa’s exit change the race?

If he leaves and endorses Andrew Cuomo, it could consolidate anti-Mamdani votes and boost Cuomo’s chances of winning the mayor’s office.