Key Takeaways

• A top adviser to GOP candidate Jack Ciattarelli made antisemitic comments and called for banning gay marriage.
• Ciattarelli praised the adviser at the same event, drawing sharp criticism.
• Democratic rival Mikie Sherrill demands a public apology, the adviser’s firing, and a clear denouncement.
• Ciattarelli denies opposing same-sex marriage and shifts blame to his opponent.
• The incident could reshape the New Jersey governor’s race and voter attitudes.

Jack Ciattarelli faces fierce criticism after an ally in his inner circle made hateful remarks. His unpaid Muslim relations adviser, Ibrar Nadeem, reportedly said people should ban gay marriage and made a crude joke about Jewish money. Those antisemitic comments emerged at a Saturday gathering, just as Ciattarelli stood with him on stage.

At that event, Nadeem claimed he hears accusations of “taking money from Jews.” He answered, “I check my bank account every day, brother, it is not there.” He also argued that same-sex marriage should not be allowed. Ciattarelli then praised Nadeem as a path-breaking adviser, calling him “a vital voice in my campaign.”

Within hours, Democratic Rep. Mikie Sherrill blasted Ciattarelli in a social media post. She demanded her rival “denounce these comments, fire the individual responsible, and apologize for praising him right after he made these antisemitic and homophobic statements.”

How antisemitic comments reached the campaign

Politico first reported the adviser’s remarks on Wednesday. Since then, both campaigns have traded barbs over who will show stronger leadership and moral clarity.

Ibrar Nadeem is a well-known figure in local interfaith circles. He volunteered to advise Ciattarelli on Muslim outreach. However, his public statements have now overshadowed his community work. The antisemitic comments cut deeply in a diverse state where Jewish families live in almost every county.

Critics say Ciattarelli should have intervened immediately. Instead, he stood by his adviser on stage. This raised questions about the candidate’s judgment and priorities. Many wonder whether Ciattarelli truly rejects hateful views or simply overlooks them for political gain.

Opponent’s call for action

Mikie Sherrill wasted no time in pressing her case. She pointed out that Ciattarelli had yet to fire Nadeem. She also highlighted his praise of the adviser, calling it “absolutely disgraceful.” In her view, silence equals consent.

Sherrill wrote, “It’s 2025 and The Jack Campaign opposes same-sex marriage. This blatant antisemitism is coming from a member of Jack’s inner circle. Jack could have condemned it but instead sang his praises.” Those words strike at a core question: Will the candidate act decisively when bigotry shows up in his ranks?

Candidate’s defense and deflection

Ciattarelli quickly responded, insisting he does not oppose same-sex marriage. He also attempted to shift attention to Sherrill by tying her to a New York City candidate named Zohran Mamdani, who runs as a Democratic Socialist. Ciattarelli suggested that extremism lurks in various corners of the Democratic Party.

Furthermore, Ciattarelli said he regrets any misunderstanding and will continue to work with people from all backgrounds. However, he stopped short of apologizing for praising Nadeem at the event. He has not said whether he will replace his adviser.

Wider impact on the governor’s race

As the campaign enters its final stretch, this controversy may sway undecided voters. New Jersey voters often look for decency and respect in their leaders. They may see the antisemitic comments and Ciattarelli’s praise as a sign he tolerates bigotry.

Moreover, some Republican voters feel the party needs strong stances against hate. They might ask whether Ciattarelli can unite a diverse coalition if he fails to address blatant prejudice. On the other hand, core GOP supporters could view this as another example of Democrats weaponizing politics.

Public reaction has been swift. Jewish, LGBTQ, and interfaith groups have condemned the antisemitic comments and called for immediate action. Several community leaders plan to hold a joint press conference this week to demand clear steps from the campaign.

Campaign watchers say Ciattarelli’s next move will be critical. If he fires his adviser and issues a forceful denouncement of antisemitic comments, he may calm the storm. But if he continues to defend Nadeem, he risks long-term damage to his image.

Context in New Jersey politics

New Jersey has a history of moderate GOP governors who appeal to centrist voters. However, the state also has a large and active Jewish community. Any sign of antisemitism can backfire quickly.

Furthermore, support for LGBTQ rights is strong among New Jersey voters. Polls show over 60 percent back same-sex marriage. Thus, Nadeem’s call to ban gay marriage could hurt Ciattarelli among suburban and younger voters.

Meanwhile, Sherrill has rallied key Democratic figures to her cause. She aims to draw a sharp contrast with Ciattarelli on civil rights and inclusion. Her campaign has released ads that quote Nadeem’s statements and frame the issue as a test of character.

What to watch next

Over the coming days, voters will watch for these signs:
• Whether Ciattarelli fires his adviser.
• If he offers a full apology for praising antisemitic comments.
• How Sherrill frames this controversy in her final ads.
• Reactions from key community groups and local leaders.

Ultimately, this episode could determine the tone of the race. If hate goes unchecked, it may overshadow policy debates on taxes, schools, and healthcare. Conversely, a swift and genuine response might restore focus on the issues voters care about most.

FAQs

What exactly did the adviser say?

He said people accused him of “taking money from Jews” and joked, “I check my bank account every day, brother, it is not there.” He also spoke against same-sex marriage.

How did Jack Ciattarelli respond?

Ciattarelli praised the adviser at the event. Later, he denied opposing gay marriage and shifted attention to his Democratic rival but did not apologize for his praise.

What does Mikie Sherrill want?

Sherrill demands Ciattarelli publicly denounce the antisemitic comments, fire his adviser, and apologize for praising him right after the remarks.

Could this hurt Ciattarelli’s campaign?

Yes. New Jersey voters value tolerance and equality. Failing to address bigotry could alienate key groups and undecided voters.