Key takeaways

• Giants GM Joe Schoen tried to trade players like Evan Neal and Jalin Hyatt
• Teams did not offer valuable picks or players in return
• Neither Neal nor Hyatt drew serious trade interest
• Giants now likely keep both players for the season
• This outcome could affect roster plans going forward

Giants Trade Targets and Interest Levels

General manager Joe Schoen entered last week ready to make moves. He asked teams about trading tackle Evan Neal and receiver Jalin Hyatt. However, no deal met his standards. In fact, interest barely registered. As a result, both players remain in New York for now.

Reasons Behind Trade Talks

First, cap space played a role. The Giants need to clear salary money to pay key stars. In addition, they want more draft picks to build depth. Consequently, Schoen explored options. He hoped to turn underperforming players into future assets.

Second, both Neal and Hyatt struggled early on. Evan Neal, a first-round pick, failed to grab a starting spot. Meanwhile, rookie Jalin Hyatt saw limited snaps and no big plays. Therefore, rival teams viewed them as risky bets. As a result, return offers didn’t meet the Giants’ asking price.

Evan Neal’s Trade Value

Neal’s size and potential still excite scouts. Standing nearly 6-foot-7 and weighing close to 350 pounds, he fits a left tackle role. Moreover, his arm length helps protect quarterbacks. Yet, he has missed key assignments and penalties mar his play.

Consequently, teams weighed his upside against his inconsistency. While some analysts called him a future star, others saw red flags. Thus, when the Giants pitched a possible swap, offers fell flat. No team surrendered high draft picks for him. Instead, some asked to add players or mid-round selections.

Jalin Hyatt’s Market Performance

Hyatt dominated college defenses with his speed and route running. However, the NFL game slowed him down. He caught few passes and rarely threatened deep. Additionally, he struggled to learn the playbook quickly. Therefore, teams looked elsewhere for veteran receivers.

During trade talks, the Giants asked for at least a mid-round draft pick. Yet, rival teams believed they could find better value later in the draft. As a result, Hyatt’s trade return proved minimal. In fact, some clubs offered small conditional picks that hardly excite.

What Defines a Meaningful Return?

A meaningful return includes high draft picks or proven players. For example, a first- or second-round pick holds big value. Alternatively, teams might part with experienced starters. In both cases, the Giants would gain assets to improve now or later.

However, a low-round pick or a practice squad player means little. Such offers rarely move the needle for a rebuilding club. In this scenario, Schoen drew the line. Instead, he decided the trade market undervalued his players.

How This Impacts the Giants’ Season

First, keeping Neal and Hyatt gives more time for growth. Coaches may adjust practice plans to boost their skills. Also, both players can benefit from more game reps this year. Consequently, they get a chance to prove their worth.

Second, the roster remains crowded. With no trades, the Giants face tough decisions on game day rosters. Veterans might lose snaps. Ultimately, competition could spark better play across the board.

Third, fans may wonder if the front office misjudged market value. However, in the long run, sticking to high-asset deals could pay off. The Giants still have draft capital and cap space for future deals.

Looking Ahead: Possible Moves

Meanwhile, Joe Schoen still has tools in his toolbox. He can revisit trade talks at the deadline if performance shifts. Alternatively, he may focus on free agency next offseason. In addition, internal trades between position groups could help.

Moreover, players like linebackers and defensive backs might draw more interest. If those talks succeed, the Giants could finally land the picks they want. Therefore, keeping patience seems key in the rebuilding process.

Conclusion

Ultimately, Giants trade plans hit a roadblock. Neither Evan Neal nor Jalin Hyatt generated meaningful offers. As a result, both remain on the roster to help the franchise grow. In addition, this outcome highlights the value of holding out for top assets. Moving forward, the Giants will balance patience with urgency to rebuild a contender.

FAQs

What factors make a return valuable in a trade?

A valuable return can be a high draft pick or an established player. First- and second-round picks offer top talent. Plus, proven starters help immediately. Together, these assets boost team depth or aid in championship runs.

Why did teams shy away from trading for Evan Neal?

Teams saw Neal’s physical traits but feared his inconsistency. Penalties and missed blocks hurt his case. Consequently, rival clubs hesitated to give up big assets for him.

Could Hyatt improve enough to spark trade interest later?

Yes. If Hyatt shows speed and reliable catching in games, interest may grow. Consistency in route running and practice footage also matters. If he steps up, the market could shift.

What could the Giants do next to build their roster?

They might explore trades for other positions, like linebacker or cornerback. Free agency and the upcoming draft are options too. In addition, focusing on player development remains crucial. Source: https://www.nydailynews.com/2025/11/04/giants-do-nothing-at-nfl-trade-deadline-as-jets-dump-players-cowboys-load-up/