Key Takeaways
• Brad Karp, chair of Paul Weiss, was heckled at a New York Bar Foundation event.
• Protesters still oppose the firm’s deal to restore security clearances for former President Trump.
• Karp defended Paul Weiss’s ongoing pro bono work, pledging $175 million in 2025.
• The event also honored leading lawyers, a sports star, and a former attorney general.
Paul Weiss Chair Faces Heckling at Bar Event
Brad Karp, the leader of the Paul Weiss law firm, stepped up to speak at the New York Bar Foundation’s 75th anniversary event. Yet, his remarks did not go unchallenged. Dozens of protesters lined the entrance of Gotham Hall holding “No Kings” signs. Inside, one lone heckler repeatedly asked about Trump as Karp praised the firm’s pro bono record.
Why Paul Weiss Made the Deal
In March, Paul Weiss met with former President Trump after an executive order stripped the firm’s lawyers of certain security clearances. Trump agreed to restore those clearances in exchange for $40 million worth of free legal help during his presidency. The deal sparked anger online. Critics called it a betrayal of principles. They argued that a top firm should not appear to side with a president facing legal challenges.
Heckling at Paul Weiss Chair’s Speech
When Karp took the stage last Friday, he reminded the audience why the firm made that deal. He said the order threatened the safety and reputation of Paul Weiss lawyers. He also highlighted how the firm continued to tackle important cases for people in need. However, as he listed the firm’s pro bono wins, one voice in the crowd shouted, “For Trump?” That heckle echoed the anger over the March agreement.
Paul Weiss’s Ongoing Pro Bono Push
Despite the backlash, Brad Karp stressed that Paul Weiss never backed down on pro bono work. He detailed how the firm plans to devote $175 million to free legal services in 2025. He pointed out that the firm’s lawyers help survivors of abuse, immigrants, and others without access to justice. By contrast, some critics saw the pledge as a way to ease guilt over the Trump deal. Yet Karp framed it as core to the firm’s mission.
Equity and Inclusion at the Bar Foundation Event
Chief Judge Cheryl E. Chambers of the New York Supreme Court opened the celebration with remarks on equity and inclusion in law. She spoke about making the legal field fairer for people of all backgrounds. Then the foundation recognized several honorees:
• Carrie H. Cohen, a partner at Morrison Foerster, for her work in corporate law.
• Whitney Chatterjee, chief legal officer at Apollo Global Management, for her leadership in finance.
• Jalen Brunson, New York Knicks captain, for his community outreach.
• Loretta E. Lynch, former U.S. attorney general, for her service to justice.
A Night of Mixed Messages
While Karp spoke, the protest outside signaled that some still question Paul Weiss’s choices. Meanwhile, inside, the event celebrated progress in diversity and public service. Loretta Lynch closed the evening with a call to defend the rule of law. She warned that doubt is spreading about whether leaders can be held accountable. Although she did not name Trump, her message resonated with the night’s tension.
Why the Heckling Matters
This incident shows how polarizing the Trump era remains, even in legal circles. A top firm like Paul Weiss cannot ignore public opinion. For many, legal battles involving the president cut to the heart of fairness in America. When critics see a firm strike a deal with a controversial leader, they may lose trust. Thus, the heckling at the Bar Foundation event could signal a longer fight over law firms’ roles in politics.
Looking Ahead for Paul Weiss
Brad Karp must now balance two goals: defending the firm’s decision on security clearances while maintaining its image as a champion of justice. He will likely face more questions as Trump remains active in politics. At the same time, Paul Weiss aims to highlight its pro bono impact. If the firm meets its $175 million pledge for 2025, it could win back some critics. Yet skeptics might still see the move as damage control.
Lessons for Law Firms in the Political Spotlight
This episode offers a lesson for any firm entwined with political figures. First, transparency is key. Law firms should clearly explain why they make controversial deals. Second, actions speak louder than words. A high pro bono pledge can show genuine commitment to public good. Third, critics may never fully forgive perceived concessions. Once trust is lost, it takes more than speeches to rebuild it.
Final Thoughts
The heckling of Brad Karp shows that public opinion can reach even the most prestigious law events. While the firm defends its deal and celebrates its pro bono work, tension remains. The New York Bar Foundation event mixed cheers for progress with chants of protest. As law firms navigate politics, they must weigh legal strategy against their reputation for justice.
Frequently Asked Questions
What prompted the protest against Paul Weiss?
Critics were angered by the firm’s agreement to restore Trump’s security clearances in exchange for pro bono services.
How did Brad Karp respond to the heckling?
He continued his speech, emphasized the firm’s pro bono achievements, and defended the decision as necessary.
Who else spoke at the New York Bar Foundation event?
Chief Judge Cheryl E. Chambers opened the event. Honorees included Carrie H. Cohen, Whitney Chatterjee, Jalen Brunson, and Loretta E. Lynch.
What is Paul Weiss’s pro bono goal for 2025?
The firm plans to devote $175 million worth of free legal services to public-interest causes.