Key Takeaways:

• Christian nationalism twists New Testament messages to fit politics.
• Critics say it wrongly labels empathy a “sin.”
• Selective reading of verses fuels a harsh worldview.
• True scripture calls for care and justice, not exclusion.

Christian Nationalism: What It Gets Wrong About the Bible

On a recent Christmas Eve podcast, religious scholar Dan McClellan explained how Christian nationalism often misreads the New Testament. He argued that some believers pick and choose verses to back political goals. In turn, they end up hurting many people.

McClellan wrote a book unpacking these mistakes. He showed that the Bible does not condemn caring for others. Instead, Christian nationalism uses distorted scripture to scare people away from empathy.

How Christian Nationalism Distorts Scripture

Christian nationalism sees the Bible as a rulebook for government control. However, the New Testament paints a different picture. It focuses on love, justice, and helping the poor.

For example, Jesus says, “You cannot serve God and mammon.” Yet some argue it only means we must avoid greed. They ignore the wider message against wealth hoarding. Moreover, in Matthew’s Gospel, Jesus blesses “the poor in spirit.” Critics claim this only means humble hearts. But Luke’s version says simply, “Blessed are the poor.” It clearly points to economic hardship.

In addition, Christian nationalism often skips verses that challenge power. It avoids parts that call for feeding the hungry or welcoming strangers. Instead, it highlights rules on behavior and authority. As a result, followers adopt a narrow faith that matches their politics.

The Sin of Empathy?

McClellan pointed out that some Christian nationalist leaders call empathy a “sin.” They argue feeling for outsiders somehow betrays their own community. Yet the Bible constantly urges us to show compassion.

For instance, Jesus tells a story about a good Samaritan. He helps a beaten man, even though their groups hated each other. This tale shows kindness conquers prejudice. So, when Christian nationalism says we must avoid empathy, it turns the story upside down.

Furthermore, Paul’s letters urge believers to bear one another’s burdens. He speaks about sharing resources so no one goes lacking. Such teachings clash with any claim that empathy is bad. Rather, they prove caring for others is central to faith.

Creating Meaning in the Bible

Christian nationalism treats the Bible as if each verse has a fixed, hidden code. In reality, the text has no single meaning. Readers bring their history and experiences to shape understanding.

McClellan explained that interpretation happens in a “negotiation” with the text. We ask questions and recall life lessons. Then we decide how a passage applies today. This process means multiple viewpoints can be valid. However, when politics drives the negotiation, the text bends to fit agendas.

For example, passages about judging others often get twisted. Some say Jesus meant we must never critique anyone. Yet the Gospels show him challenging religious leaders. Clearly, he saw a role for honest correction. Thus, sticking rigidly to one reading ignores the broader story.

Why Faith and Politics Should Stay Separate

When faith serves politics, it risks losing its moral compass. Christian nationalism merges church aims with state power. This blend can pressure believers and exclude outsiders.

In contrast, many Christian traditions value a clear line between faith and government. They believe religion calls for personal transformation, not political control. History shows that when the two mix closely, it leads to intolerance and conflict.

Moreover, Christian nationalism often targets specific groups. It demonizes immigrants and minorities. This approach contradicts the Bible’s call to love all people. Instead of building walls, scripture urges opening doors.

Moving Toward a Healthier Faith

If you care about genuine faith, you can guard against these distortions. First, read passages in context. Notice who wrote them, when, and why. Second, discuss scripture with people of different backgrounds. Fresh perspectives help avoid narrow views.

Next, ask how a verse calls you to serve others. Does it spark compassion or exclusion? True faith demands kindness. Finally, remember that caring for people in need reflects Jesus’ heart. Empathy unites, while fear divides.

In this way, you can practice a faith that builds bridges. You will honor the Bible’s core message of love, justice, and mercy.

FAQs

Why do some call empathy a sin?

Certain Christian nationalist leaders fear empathy for outsiders. They argue it weakens loyalty to their own group. Yet scripture shows compassion is vital to faith.

How do we know the Bible has multiple meanings?

The Bible includes various voices and genres. Readers interpret it based on history, culture, and personal experience. That makes one fixed meaning impossible.

Can I be political and faithful at the same time?

Yes, but mixing faith with strict political agendas can harm both. A healthy faith focuses on spiritual growth and serving others, not winning power.

What steps help avoid distorted readings?

Read verses alongside their context. Talk with a diverse study group. Reflect on whether a passage promotes love and justice. These steps guide toward honest understanding.