19.9 C
Los Angeles
Saturday, October 11, 2025

Why Did the Court Reject Journalist Mario Guevara’s Appeal?

  Key Takeaways: A federal appeals court dismissed...

Why Is Trump Sending National Guard Troops to Chicago?

  Key Takeaways: President Trump has sent 300...

Why Is Trump Sending 300 National Guard Troops to Chicago?

  Key Takeaways: President Trump has approved deploying...

Trump Order Threatens DEI in Schools

PoliticsTrump Order Threatens DEI in Schools

Key Takeaways
– The education department warned schools to remove DEI discipline rules.
– Trump’s letter acts like a law and threatens to cut funding.
– Half of all states refuse to comply and cite legal concerns.
– Nineteen states sued and won a court injunction in April.
– Schools face mixed messages on how to handle discipline and DEI work.

What Is the Dear Colleague Letter
In February 2025 the Department of Education sent a letter to every school that gets federal money. The letter said schools must stop any discipline methods tied to diversity equity and inclusion. It even gave schools two weeks to drop these rules or risk losing funds. Previous presidents used such letters as advice. But this one reads like a law that demands action.

Why DEI Matters in Schools
Diversity equity and inclusion aims to help students from all backgrounds learn and grow. In discipline it means talking through issues before suspending students. Research shows these steps cut down harsh punishments for Black Latino and Native American students. Under Obama schools that did not use fair discipline faced discrimination probes. In 2014 his Dear Colleague letter urged nonpunitive options not more suspensions. Then in 2018 the first Trump administration scrapped that letter. In 2023 the Biden team brought it back in a similar form. Now the new Trump letter groups all those ideas under DEI and says they harm white and Asian students.

Trump’s Executive Order on Discipline
In April 2025 Trump backed up his letter with an executive order called Reinstating Commonsense School Discipline Policy. The order says that if schools keep DEI programs they break Title VI of the Civil Rights Act. That law bans race discrimination in schools that take federal money. The executive order is binding and not just advice. It marks the first time any president tied K-12 funding to such a direct threat.

States Push Back
So far nearly half the states refuse to follow the new rules. By May 30 two states had not answered at all. Twenty-three states signed on and said they would comply. Oklahoma went further and banned DEI through a new state law. The other twenty-five states said they already follow Title VI. They argued this extra paper work is redundant under the Paperwork Reduction Act. Some like Illinois and Minnesota even cited past support for DEI from Trump’s first education secretary.

Legal Challenges to the Order
In April nineteen states filed a lawsuit against the Department of Education over the letter. They claimed it oversteps federal power and lacks a legal basis. Later that month a court issued an injunction. This order blocks the administration from cutting funding over DEI programs for now. It leaves schools free to keep any DEI work they already have in place.

Why States Are Resisting
Many states that fight the order use the same words in their letters. Their shared language shows a united front against it. Most point to laws that already protect civil rights. They say they cannot be forced to re-certify compliance with Title VI. Some also worry the order does not even define what counts as DEI. That leaves school districts unsure if they must drop class discussions or student groups.

Different Kinds of Pushback
Some states resist on legal grounds. Others speak up for DEI’s role in learning. The Massachusetts interim education commissioner said diversity improves outcomes for all kids. Kansas’s commissioner restated a commitment to follow federal law but did not mention the letter by name. Kentucky told the department it will obey Title VI and still back local DEI efforts. Mississippi said its school boards decide policy and pointed out districts already filed Title VI certificates.

What Comes Next for Schools
At this point the injunction shields states from losing funds over DEI work. Yet the long-term outcome remains unclear. The administration has not said when it might enforce threats to cut funding. Meanwhile schools must navigate conflicting signals. Some districts will halt DEI programs to avoid risk. Others may continue their work.

What Students and Parents Should Know
First parents need to watch how their local school boards react. Second they should ask if any policy changes affect student support groups or lesson plans. Third they might reach out to state education officials to learn more. Finally they can join public comment periods on new state or district rules.

Conclusion
Trump’s letter and executive order break new ground in school policy. They call on states to treat a policy suggestion like a binding rule. Many states are pushing back with legal and practical objections. For now a court has paused the threat of losing funds. Yet the situation remains unsettled. Schools and families will need to stay alert as this debate moves forward.

Check out our other content

Most Popular Articles