Key Takeaways:

• Vice President JD Vance said the killing of Renee Good was “a tragedy of her own making.”
• ICE agent Jonathan Ross shot and killed Good as she tried to drive away.
• Progressive YouTuber Brian Tyler Cohen called Vance “depraved and soulless.”
• The debate over ICE immunity and accountability has sparked nationwide protests.

JD Vance’s Defense of ICE Officers

On Thursday, Vice President JD Vance spoke about an ICE raid that ended in tragedy. The raid involved agent Jonathan Ross, who shot and killed 37-year-old Renee Good. Good was unarmed and tried to drive away after dropping her child off at school. Yet Vance blamed Good, calling her death a result of her own actions.

During a White House briefing, JD Vance said ICE officers have “absolute immunity.” He argued the agents carry out important national security work. He insisted that their decisions are protected by law. His words came just one day after Renee Good’s death on Wednesday.

Vance’s remarks angered many. Protesters gathered in cities across the country. They marched with signs demanding justice for Good. Meanwhile, critics said blaming the victim deflects attention from unchecked ICE power.

Why JD Vance Blamed Renee Good

First, JD Vance described the shooting as a “regrettable incident.” He added that Good tried to flee in her car. According to Vance, this choice triggered the officer’s response. He claimed the agent acted within his legal rights.

However, witnesses say Good posed no threat. They say she simply wanted to return home. They stress she had just dropped her child at school. Yet Vance maintained the focus on her decision to drive off.

Furthermore, Vance warned against second-guessing law enforcement. He argued that agents need confidence to do their work. As a result, he pressed for public support. Critics see this as a refusal to investigate deeper.

Reactions from Brian Tyler Cohen

Progressive YouTuber Brian Tyler Cohen posted a reaction video on Thursday night. He described the vice president’s response as “depraved and soulless.” He said it “fills my body with rage” to hear such comments.

Cohen highlighted that Good was a single mom. She had no criminal record. She simply tried to avoid danger. Yet Vance’s words painted her actions as reckless. Cohen argued this shows a lack of basic humanity.

In his video, Cohen said it is impossible to reason with an administration that devalues human life. He urged viewers to demand accountability for ICE officers. He also called for Congress to limit ICE’s immunity.

The video quickly went viral. It scored millions of views in less than a day. In addition, it trended on multiple social media platforms. Supporters praised Cohen for speaking out. Critics said he was unfair to the vice president.

Nationwide Protests Grow

Following Good’s death, protests erupted in dozens of cities. Crowds gathered outside ICE offices and local courthouses. They carried signs like “Justice for Renee” and “ICE Must Answer.”

Protesters chanted for changes in immigration policy. They demanded independent investigations of deadly raids. They also called on lawmakers to strip ICE of immunity protections.

In some places, rallies remained peaceful. Yet a few escalated into clashes with police. Several arrests took place. Organizers warned that more protests are planned.

What Happens Next

Lawmakers are now under pressure to act. Some Democrats have already called for hearings on ICE practices. They aim to examine the legal shield that agents enjoy.

Republicans have defended ICE immunity as essential for national security. They argue that agents must act without fear of personal lawsuits. That split in Congress may stall any quick fixes.

Meanwhile, the Justice Department announced a preliminary review. It will look into the use of force by Jonathan Ross. This review could take months. Families and activists worry it won’t go far enough.

In the coming days, more leaders will speak out. The White House may issue statements in response to protests. Grassroots groups plan rallies in state capitals. They want justice for Renee Good and changes to immigration enforcement.

The case has also reached social media. Hashtags demanding ICE reform trended nationwide. People shared stories of loved ones affected by ICE raids. This online pressure could push lawmakers to act faster.

In the midst of it all, JD Vance’s comments continue to spark debate. Supporters say he stood up for law and order. Critics say he showed a lack of empathy. The country remains divided on how to balance security and human rights.

As tensions rise, both sides are gearing up for a long fight. The outcome could reshape immigration policy for years to come. In the meantime, Renee Good’s family awaits answers and accountability.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did JD Vance say about the shooting?

JD Vance called the shooting a “tragedy of her own making” and emphasized ICE agents’ legal immunity.

Who was Renee Good?

Renee Good was a 37-year-old U.S. citizen. She was unarmed and tried to drive away after dropping her child at school.

Why did Brian Tyler Cohen react strongly?

Cohen called the vice president’s remarks “depraved and soulless,” arguing they showed a lack of humanity.

What is ICE immunity?

ICE immunity shields officers from personal lawsuits over actions taken in the line of duty, unless there is clear evidence of wrongdoing.